Storming Crab Pigeon Forge: An Honest Review

Storming Crab seafood boil with lobster tail and corn, the Pigeon Forge dining room and fried shrimp with fries

Is the Storming Crab worth it? An honest review

For years, seafood options in the mountains were limited. Most of your choices involved fried catfish or maybe an upscale trout joint. Of course, you had chain options like Red Lobster or other places that dabbled in seafood on their menus, but true seafood experiences were few and far between. 

That’s changed in recent years, and like anything in the mountains, with success comes copycats. The good news is, it’s easier than ever to get good seafood in the mountains. The bad news? It can be fairly expensive. And that’s where the Storming Crab comes in, offering Cajun-style seafood boils and dishes at mostly reasonable prices. 

But is the Storming Crab the best seafood in the mountains? Well, we’ll get to that, but it does have a nice combination of relative quality and affordability. 

Dining room inside Storming Crab in Pigeon Forge
Storming Crab has locations across the United States (photo by John Gullion/TheSmokies.com)

What is the Storming Crab? 

It is a minor chain with locations from Las Vegas to South Dakota and into New York state. The heaviest presence is in Tennessee, Kentucky and Southern Indiana. Should we be concerned that there are no Storming Crab restaurants in Louisiana, Southern Mississippi or along the Gulf Coast at all? Yeah. Maybe a little. The closest to the Gulf Coast is just south of Ocala, Florida, on I-75. After that you’re looking at an 8-10 hour drive from the coast to the next closest one. 

The Storming Crab in the Smokies is a heavily themed Cajun seafood restaurant on the strip in Pigeon Forge, not far from the Jurassic Jungle Boat ride. Featured menu items are a variety of shrimp, crawfish, lobster and a variety of crab legs. They are done in the boil style which includes sausage, potatoes and corn in the pot, soaking up the heavy Cajun spices. 

They can build your boil to order from their variety of seafood and fixins and can spice to your preference. We were cautious. I don’t handle the Cajun heat as well as I used to. But I was left wishing we’d gone up a couple of levels of spiciness. If you’re not in the mood for a seafood boil, they have a variety of fried seafood baskets and raw oysters. Sides include gumbo, etouffee and a dirty rice.

The atmosphere is loose and jaunty – there’s a big ship hull in the dining room and guests have been encouraged to write on the walls and everywhere except the bathrooms. Bibs, gloves and the other accoutrements required for cracking seafood are provided. 

It’s fun. Lighthearted. 

Lobster tail, corn and potatoes in a Storming Crab seafood boil
A plate of crab boil seafood at Storming Crab (photo by John Gullion/TheSmokies.com)

What’s on the menu? 

Apps include crab cakes and boudin balls and southern favorites like hush puppies, fried okra and sweet potato fries. There’s also the mozzarella cheese sticks which aren’t particularly Cajun but are required by law on every U.S. menu. For your entrée, in addition to the oysters are the fried baskets. You can choose from calamari, soft shell crab, gator, catfish as well as chicken strips. 

The boils come with already paired options like crawfish and shrimp or Dungeness Crab, shrimp and clams. There are also a couple of King Crab options. Or you can design your own choosing from Snow Crab, lobster tail, scallops, black or green mussels, crawfish, shrimp or the Dungeness crab. You can add extra corn, potatoes, sausage, egg or broccoli to the mix. 

Each of the dinner combos can feed two or three people. Prices range from around $50 to well over $100 depending on your preferences. Boil flavors include Crab House Cajun, Old Bay Butter or Garlic Butter. You can also order the boil without seasoning but unless there’s an allergy issue, I don’t know why you would. Heat options range from mild to super-hot and up to Sam’s Special. I don’t know who Sam is, but he has an impressive tolerance for pain. 

Shrimp, crab legs and green beans in a Storming Crab seafood boil
I found the shrimp to be the best part of the seafood boil (photo by John Gullion/TheSmokies.com)

Is the seafood boil at Storming Crab authentic? And is it good?

Recommending a seafood place is a difficult game. Everyone’s seafood expectations are different. If you grew up in the middle of Indiana as I did, your palate might be more accepting of lesser seafood. However, if you learned to eat seafood with your Papaw’s neighbor – a commercial crabber – on Florida’s Nature Coast – as I also did – your tolerance for seafood that’s anything less than fresh off the boat could lead you to be a seafood snob as I was for a long time. 

Today? I’m somewhere in the middle of all that when it comes to seafood. 

And so, I found that the Storming Crab is pretty good for what it is. A Cajun-themed Pigeon Forge seafood restaurant on the strip. The shrimp – for me – were the best part of our boil but then again, shrimp are my favorite anyway. The crab was good as was the lobster but we tried a modestly priced boil. At double the price, I would have expected a significant uptick in quality. Since I didn’t order the high-end stuff, I can’t tell you whether or not the Storming Crab rises to that standard. 

As it was we had a perfectly enjoyable meal. The apps were fine. Our calamari-crazy youngest daughter enjoyed her basket and the boy – who is allergic to seafood – said the chicken strips were acceptable.

Fried seafood basket with fries at Storming Crab
The Storming Crab, in this local’s opinion, comes in behind Chesapeake’s and Pinchy’s (pictured is a fried seafood basket) (photo by John Gullion/TheSmokies.com)

Where does the Storming Crab rank in Smoky Mountain seafood?

I’m not ready to fully make that assessment just yet. 

Certainly, it’s behind Chesapeake’s and Pinchy’s but also more affordable than those two in general. I think Harpoon Harry’s is the nearest comp and I think I like Harry’s better but would probably like to eat at each place again just to make sure. In terms of Cajun flavors, Paw Paw’s Catfish Kitchen in Wears Valley is more authentic and doesn’t try and pander to those who can’t handle the Cajun spice. 

Still, it does have fun vibes and a decent bar selection. 

While we need a little more time to assess its place in the Smoky Mountain hierarchy, you could certainly do a lot worse for a meal in the Smokies. 

Storming Crab Pigeon Forge FAQ

Where is the Storming Crab in Pigeon Forge?

It’s on the strip in Pigeon Forge, not far from the Jurassic Jungle Boat ride.

How much does the Storming Crab cost?

Each of the dinner combos can feed two or three people, and prices range from around $50 to well over $100 depending on what you order.

What’s on the menu besides seafood boils?

Fried baskets (calamari, soft shell crab, gator, catfish and chicken strips), raw oysters, and apps like crab cakes, boudin balls and hush puppies. Sides include gumbo, etouffee and dirty rice.

How spicy are the boils?

You pick the heat. Boil flavors include Crab House Cajun, Old Bay Butter and Garlic Butter, and heat ranges from mild to super-hot and up to Sam’s Special.

Is the Storming Crab worth it?

It’s pretty good for what it is: a fun, lighthearted Cajun-themed seafood spot. In this local’s opinion it ranks behind Chesapeake’s and Pinchy’s, but it’s generally more affordable than those two.

Are you excited about the Storming Crab? Let us know what you think in the comments and on the socials!

Share to: