I grew up on old folk tales and stories of haints courtesy of my grandmother, whose favorite was James Whitcomb Riley’s “Little Orphant Annie” about the goblins who punish naughty children.
Those stories were fine in the light of day but when night fell, especially when it fell far away from the warm confines of your home, those stories had a way of resurfacing in the imagination. That remains especially true of the Smokies after dark. A completely rational person by day can be unnerved by the rustling of the wind, the amplified crack of a twig or the howl of the coyotes in the distance. I know the biggest danger of venturing into the woods at night is simply getting lost, which is why I never get too far from the tent or camper or when stargazing near the Cove parking lot.
The Smokies has a tradition of mysteries dating back before Europeans set foot at Plymouth Rock. The Cherokee legends of Spearfinger and Stoneman gave way to the ghost stories that eventually trickled through the ages to my grandmother, and on to me.
Do I believe in the strange tales, ancient mysteries and legends of the mountains? Sitting here, in the warm glow of a computer monitor in my comfortable office? No, of course not. But put me in the mountains on a windy night with the moon wandering in and out of the coverage of the clouds and ask me then. I might be inclined to be on the lookout for goblins.

Strange Sightings in Cades Cove and Beyond
The truth is, I’m not a believer in ghosts. Have I allowed myself to be spooked a bit? Yeah. I think that’s natural. But I’ve never seen anything that would allow me to believe that our spirits remain after we are gone.
However, if there was a place ripe for haunting, it would be a place like the Cove or maybe the Roaring Fork. The people of the Cove lived lives of toil and struggle; they fought hard simply to survive. Many had a deep and familial connection to the land. The same with the houses their ancestors built by hand. Me? I’ve lived in 20 or more different places over the years. Even if my spirit wanted to haunt one of my former homes, how in the world would it choose? I’d just be commuting spectrally all the time.
The people of the mountain weren’t like that. They had roots that ran deep. And then it was taken away. Sure, they were compensated. Sure, most stalwarts got to live out their days in the park. But for many, those for whom the mountains were part of their soul, it was nothing short of a grieving loss. And so, if you were to convince me of ghosts, it would need to be a place like the old cabins built by families who lived in them for generations.

Getting the Chills at an Old Homestead
I brought that up because a while back, my family and I were in the mountains exploring one of the old homesteads. At one of them, there was a National Park Service sign that gave the history of the site and had a picture of the last resident there. Another family was visiting at the same time and one of their girls wandered away from the group, not far, to check out a side building.
I wasn’t trying to spy, but I overheard her come back and ask her mom about the lady she saw. When the rest of the family went over, there was no one there.
There weren’t any other groups at the cabin at that time, just my family and hers. I was resting over by the sign as my family explored the rest of the site. I had to move a bit when the other family came over to read the history on the sign. So, I was there when the little girl pointed and told her mom that was the lady she saw. It was the middle of the day. A fine, soft summer afternoon. And I got chills that ran the entire length of my spine and then some.
Articles Related to Mysteries in the Smokies and Beyond
- Check out the 7 Most Haunted Places in Gatlinburg, TN – Do you dare to visit?
- Legends and lore – Truth or Fiction in the Smokies
- 5 Mysterious Smoky Mountain Disappearances That Remain Unsolved Today
- Have you visited Biltmore? – 9 Most Likely Ghosts, Haunted Places at the Biltmore
- The Wild Smoky Mountain Legend of a Woman Known as ‘Spearfinger’ – Read more!

Strange Voices in Cades Cove
If you go on YouTube, there’s a cottage industry of people trying to give you the heebie-jeebies. Strange voices in the Cove, in the mountains and while in your car. Most of the time, I chalk it up to people being dramatic, somebody off camera just stage whispering their butt off. We do love a good scare, so I imagine there are pretty good clicks in it.
But I’ve also spent a lot of time in the mountains. It ain’t as peaceful sonically as some may have you believe. There’s a reason, after all, that the Roaring Fork Branch is called that. When the water is up and the wind is high, the mountains can be a noisy place. It can be hard to hear clearly. Our natural ability to tell where sound is coming from gets thrown off. And not being able to trust your senses will disorient you quickly. A trick of the wind, or an unfamiliar noise that is hard to place among the other sounds can really set the imagination spinning.
But it goes beyond that, too. In and around the cabins – which were expertly built for the time – the wind and its sound can move oddly. Voices will carry in ways you might not expect. Suddenly an innocent laugh from someone who is not in your line of sight can carry an unexpected menace. And so, there are reports – especially around the Cove’s cabins – of strange voices, unexplained whispers and ghostly mutterings. I don’t put a lot of stock in them. But I can’t tell you I haven’t been in one of the cabins and had the hair on the back of my neck raised.

The Disappearance of Dennis Martin
Not all the mysteries of the mountains are ethereal. In 1969, Dennis Martin was six years old when he went hiking in the high mountains with his dad, granddad and older brother. It was Father’s Day weekend and they hiked from Cades Cove to Russell Field where they camped. The next day they made it to Spence Field, a highland meadow not far from the Appalachian Trail.
They were hanging out with another family when the boys decided they’d creep up and scare the adults. Dennis went one way. The other boys went the other. No one ever saw Dennis again.
Dennis was out of sight for a few minutes when his father began searching. The search quickly turned frantic. The grandfather hiked out and got Park Service rangers but the area up there is marked by steep slopes and ravines.
A massive downpour overnight drenched the area and combined with an ill-fated search attempt to erase any signs that could have led to finding Dennis. Why ill-fated? Among the searchers were Boy Scouts who left Dennis-size tracks. The National Guard and Green Berets got involved. Dennis was gone without a trace.
In the wake of the disappearance various theories developed. People talked about Wild Men – humanoid cannibals living in the deep forest – or Bigfoot. Maybe an abductor on the AT happened to be in the right place at the right time. More mundane theories included wild animal attacks or a deadly fall into the rushing water.

The Disappearance of Trenny Gibson
A few years after Dennis disappeared, so did Trenny Gibson, on a school trip to Kuwohi in 1976. Trenny had been on a trail with friends, gone ahead and was never seen again. Speculation over the years has thrown suspicion on classmates or suggested that Trenny had made arrangements to meet up with someone and run off. Maybe she got lost and ran into the wrong person and was abducted.

What Happened to Dennis Martin and Trenny Gibson?
It wasn’t wild men or Bigfeet or goblins. It was most likely bad luck or, in Trenny’s case, a violent act by an acquaintance, or someone else on the trails.
The most likely theory is Dennis got lost and scared. It’s impossible to hear very much up in the high mountains and he wouldn’t have had to have gone far to be out of earshot. The storms came and he was scared and hid and died alone. Maybe from an animal, maybe from hypothermia.
Why weren’t Dennis’ remains ever found? They might have been. In 1985 a ginseng hunter claimed to have found the remains of a child in Big Hollow at Tremont years earlier. He kept his find to himself because he feared being prosecuted for poaching ginseng illegally.
Dennis’ father believed he was abducted. Weeks after the disappearance, a tourist from Middle Tennessee claimed to have heard a scream and seen someone running up a trail, carrying something large and jumping into a car to speed off. The details were a bit sketchy as some time had passed. The claim also was dependent on Dennis being five miles away from where he was lost at roughly the same time. It’s unlikely Dennis could have covered that distance through heavy brush in time. It’s even more unlikely a single person could have carried him all that way over that terrain.

What About Trenny?
For Trenny, there is some belief she tried to take a shortcut back to the Kuwohi parking lot and some evidence she took a wrong turn and found herself up on the Appalachian Trail. Maybe she got lost. Maybe she was attacked. But you would have thought, if she hadn’t gotten too far, that the subsequent searches – including some with bloodhounds – would have found something more than the hints and rumors that followed for years to come.

Other Smoky Mountain Mysteries
There are fewer places of true mystery in the world than there used to be. But the great wild places like the Smoky Mountains could still harbor untold secrets.
Are there ghosts? Bigfeet? Panthers? Wild People? Probably not. But the park is just big enough and wild enough and remote enough that the mysteries can linger.
Appalachian Mysteries in the Smokies: FAQ
What happened to Dennis Martin?
Six-year-old Dennis Martin vanished near Spence Field on Father’s Day weekend in 1969 after he split off from the other boys to sneak up on the adults. Despite a massive search, he was never found. The most likely theory is that he got lost and scared and died of exposure or an animal attack.
What happened to Trenny Gibson?
Trenny Gibson disappeared on a school trip to Kuwohi in 1976 after going ahead of her friends on a trail. Some believe she tried to take a shortcut back to the parking lot and ended up on the Appalachian Trail. Searches, including some with bloodhounds, turned up only hints and rumors.
Are there strange voices in Cades Cove?
There are reports, especially around the Cove’s cabins, of strange voices, unexplained whispers and ghostly mutterings. High water, wind and the way sound carries around the old cabins can easily throw off your sense of where a noise is coming from.
What are the oldest legends of the Smoky Mountains?
The Cherokee legends of Spearfinger and Stoneman date back before Europeans arrived. They gave way to the ghost stories and tales of haints that have trickled down through the ages.
Do you have a mysterious story to share? Let us know in the comments and on the socials! Are you planning a trip to the Smoky Mountains? Be sure to check out our coupons page for area promos.