Who has the best pizza in Gatlinburg? Here’s our top 5, ranked

Mellow Mushroom in downtown Gatlinburg

Mellow Mushroom has some of the best pizza in the Smoky Mountains (photos by Alaina O'Neal and Marie Graichen/TheSmokies.com)

Category: ,
7 Comments

Disclosure: This site is sponsored by ads and affiliate programs. We may earn money from the companies mentioned in this post. As an Amazon, Tripster and CJ Affiliate we may earn from qualifying purchases.

There’s a saying that there’s no such thing as bad pizza. But some pizza is better than others.

There are times pizza is a function. We’re tired. There’s ball practice. Somebody had a long day. Let’s just get something quick and easy that everybody likes.

Functional pizza, we’ll call it.

Then there are other times that pizza is a destination, a reward, a celebration.

Good pizza is easy.

Great pizza is an art.

There are times on vacation you might need functional pizza. You’ve had a long day at Dollywood, you’re tired.

The kids are grouchy, for the love of everything that’s holy you just need someone to get something they’ll eat to the hotel room fast so you can all eat, go to bed and get back to living your best vacation life tomorrow.

There are other times on vacation you want something a little better. The kids are in the mood for pizza but you want something that will engage your higher culinary purpose.

Read Also: Who has the best steak in Pigeon Forge, Gatlinburg? Here’s our top 5

The compromise is pizza, but great pizza.

When looking for great pizza in Gatlinburg, here are your top five best chances for transcendence:

Taste of Italy
Taste of Italy is located in the shopping center across from Food City in Gatlinburg (photo by Morgan Overholt/TheSmokies.com)

5. Taste of Italy

You can find great pizza in some higher-end locations (see No. 1 on the list), but often the search for great pizza leads us to America’s strip malls and shopping centers.

Places with high traffic and relatively low overhead.

While I can’t speak specifically to the overhead, I feel like Taste of Italy, located on East Parkway in Gatlinburg, at the far end of the Food City lot, is just that kind of place.

Opened by a pair of New Yorkers who moved to the mountains, Taste of Italy offers a lot more Italian fare than just pizza, but if you’re in the mood for a quality pie, you could do a lot worse.

There’s some variety here but nothing you won’t find on menus across the country. While I do enjoy the occasional change of pace, you can’t go wrong with the deluxe or meat lovers.

If the kids don’t want anything other than cheese or pepperoni, get them what they want and order a sausage roll or stromboli. It’ll do you right.

Best Italian
Best Italian serves New York-style pizza, hearty calzones and incredible garlic rolls (photo by Morgan Overholt/TheSmokies.com)

4. Best Italian

I’m not sure if it was the same breed of creativity that inspired the name Newfound Gap that led to the christening of this famous Gatlinburg pizza establishment.

Read Also: Where is Newfound Gap? A guide to the most scenic drive in the Smokies

Or maybe they just wanted to throw down the gauntlet at inception.

Either way, there are some high stakes involved when you choose to name your restaurant “Best”.

And yet, despite the pressure Best Italian has brought upon itself, it still somehow manages to deliver (pizza pun).

Actually, they technically don’t deliver. So perhaps that joke falls flat (pizza pun take two).

But I digress.

What I’m trying to say is, Best Italian has great pizza.

Best Italian has two locations in Gatlinburg – one in Elks Plaza and the other on the main strip downtown on the Parkway.

Their New York-style pizzas are known for their homemade taste and fresh ingredients. And their calzones are nothing short of humongous.

Plus, they even offer gluten-free options for those with special dietary needs.

Pro-tip: Don’t leave without trying the garlic rolls.

3. Smoky Mountain Brewery

My grandmother, a tiny Hoosier woman named Wilma who grew up in the Great Depression, shockingly wasn’t much of a drinker.

Her one exception?

“John Aaron, I do like a beer with my pizza,” she’d tell me, knocking back a Schlitz tall boy and tearing another slice from the pie with her hands.

I kid.

She was probably drinking Pabst.

Anyway, the idea of beer and pizza, hand in hand, goes all the back to my childhood and has been endorsed by my wonderful Nanny.

I suggest you go to the Smoky Mountain Brewery, either in Gatlinburg or Pigeon Forge, order the Baker’s Choice and a few microbrews, and celebrate in her honor.

Alternatively, order the T-Rex and spend the rest of the evening pretending you can’t reach the pizza in the middle of the table because of your implausibly short arms.

Gnashing your teeth and sneering like one of Maurice Sendak’s “Wild Things” is also recommended.

Big Daddys Pizza
Big Daddy’s Pizza is home to a one-of-a-kind brick oven. The Gatlinburg location shares a building with their sister restaurant, Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que (photo by Morgan Overholt/TheSmokies.com)

2. Big Daddy’s Pizza

The pizza game is crowded. Pie-slingers come and go.

It’s important to have a niche, an edge. The chain restaurant giants claim so much of the available business already, the others have to have a little something different to stand out.

Welcome to Big Daddy’s, featuring a 550-degree, wood-fired flame inside a one-of-a-kind brick oven.

Why is the oven one-of-a-kind and what would make one brick oven technologically superior over another? I have no idea, but it sounds impressive.

Also, Big Daddy’s is so committed to freshness, they don’t own a freezer. That’s Amish-level commitment to fresh ingredients, right there.

As for the pizza, a thing Big Daddy’s does that I really like is a tier topping system for the build-your-own options.

Silver toppings are mostly veggies, gold toppings are mostly meat and platinum toppings include things like prime rib, prosciutto and anchovies.

It’s like a little gated community for your pizza.

Read Also: Big Daddy’s Pizza in Pigeon Forge, Gatlinburg: Is it worth it?

Mellow Mushroom Gatlinburg
Mellow Mushroom has three locations in the Smokies – two in Pigeon Forge and one (pictured) on the main strip in downtown Gatlinburg (photo by Marie Graichen/TheSmokies.com)

1. Mellow Mushroom

The pizza here is great. The variety is creative and fantastic, and I’ve never had anything less than an excellent pizza at Mellow Mushroom.

Now, I’m going to tell a personal story here about why Mellow Mushroom is No. 1.

My 8-year-old son JP was born with several food allergies. None of them affect his breathing, at least that we know of. Still, if he eats something he shouldn’t, he breaks out in hives and starts itching all over. It’s miserable.

Some things affect him more than others. Beef makes him very sick. Eggs affect him almost instantly. He can have small amounts of soy without a big problem and even a little dairy sometimes.

He is usually pretty good about avoiding the foods he shouldn’t have but sometimes, I think, he feels left out.

Last year, I was called to come get him at school because he was breaking out in hives and he can’t stay after he takes his medicine.

It turns out the class was having ice cream and JP decided he wasn’t going to be left out this time.

“Buddy,” I said when I picked him up. “You know you can’t have ice cream. What happened?”

“I know, Daddy. But my brain told me to,” he said, summing up my lifetime of bad decisions better than I ever could have.

So JP, in all his years, never had pizza. When we order pizza, he gets breadsticks or crust brushed with a little butter and parmesan which we call pizza.

It’s hard to remember the role pizza plays in a child’s social life.

Pizza day is the best day at school. Birthday parties, sleepovers, end of the year ball team celebrations. Pizza is the go-to food of choice, and JP has had to sit on the sideline, wondering what all the fuss is about.

Anyway, last year, we went to the movies, and afterward went to Mellow Mushroom without checking the menu.

They didn’t have JP’s usual nuggets and fries. I was ordering a side salad and pretzel bits for him when, on a whim, I asked if they had a dairy-free cheese pizza.

Being a hippie pizza place, they did.

How my son finally had a chance to try real pizza

It took JP about 1.3 milliseconds to confirm that yes, he would very much like to try a real pizza that wouldn’t make him itch.

When they brought that thing out, John Paul looked like a king at a banquet being presented with all the finest meats and cheeses of the land.

He was so proud, so happy to have this little thing that we all take for granted.

He ate two big pieces and two more when we got home. I tried it.

It was pretty good. Tasted like normal pizza. My boy finally got to have pizza.

Look, my kids are happy and healthy and we are so lucky. I don’t mean to paint this as if we are anything close to the challenges many other families in this country face.

But Mellow Mushroom let JP sit and eat real pizza like the other kids.

That’s why they are No. 1 on my list, and the pizza’s pretty dang good, too.

Where’s your favorite place to grab pizza when you visit the Great Smoky Mountains? Let us know in the comments!

Disclaimer: While we do our best to bring you the most up-to-date information, attractions or prices mentioned in this article may vary by season and are subject to change. Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any mentioned business, and have not been reviewed or endorsed these entities. Contact us at info@thesmokies.com for questions or comments.

Things to do

Previous

Things to do in Gatlinburg with kids, our top 5 activities ranked

Is Anakeesta worth the money? An honest review

Next

7 thoughts on “Who has the best pizza in Gatlinburg? Here’s our top 5, ranked”

  1. My all time favorite is The Best Italian Pizza in Gatlinburg. Have been eating there for over 30 years and never had a bad meal! Also I do like Mellow Mushroom as well.

  2. I found Best Italian years ago and have to go there every time we’re in Gatlinburg. Best pizza around.

  3. Mellow Mushroom is the absolute worst pizza i have ever had the displeasure of eating. Yes I did eat at the one in Gatlinburg. Our whole family thought it was awful.

  4. You can get the best at Pizza Inn located just 45 minutes in Knoxville, TN. Why would anyone think that the pizza at Mellow Mushroom would be any good? More like mush pizza.

  5. Our favorite is Ski Mountain Pizza. The family that owns it is always so friendly and the food is amazing.

  6. I absolutely love Mellow Mushroom. I found your story about JP to be absolutely great. I can only imagine the happiness over the entire family that night he got to try it. I work a few blocks from away from a Mellow Mushroom pizza in Birmingham, Alabama and I have always enjoyed their pizzas and salads. Thanks so much for sharing all of your favorites! We are traveling to Gatlinburg this Christmas, and can hardly wait!
    *** Cheers***

  7. The best thin crust pizza is found in the Northeast (NY/NJ). I have yet to find anything remotely close, the Mellow Mushroom was disappointing. Pizza aside, the quality of life in TN is 200% better so if missing out on a good “Tomato Pie” is the trade off I’ll take it six ways to Sunday.

Leave a Comment